Thursday, September 18, 2014

Mesa feels organic to me

People who live in cities other than in suburbs or rural areas tend to be more liberal and vote democrat than in other places.  Researchers looked for American's most conservative city and decided it was Mesa Arizona.  (see link below).  Doesn't it seem that these cities are all described in terms of organic society with government as the heart center?  And yet, the outcomes in Mesa seem mechanistic to me in many ways.  Comments ?



Mesa, Arizona, Is America's Most Conservative City - POLITICO Magazine

8 comments:

  1. I agree with you here, Dr. McKinney. In some ways, the structure of the city as depicted in the text (even the picture and caption) seems contradictory to the city's label as "America's most conservative city."

    To your point that Mesa seems mechanistic and organic with government as the heart, I gathered the mechanistic manner from this section:

    "Essentially a Phoenix bedroom community (though some larger employers, notably Apple, have recently moved into Mesa itself), Mesa consists of endless miles of strip malls and subdivisions filled with squat ranch houses, all connected by six-lane roads where people regularly zip by at 60 miles an hour. There are also numerous mobile home communities, open only to those 55 and older—retirees apparently enjoy living in a city where summer temperatures regularly top 107 degrees. It’s hardly, in other words, an urbanist’s paradise: Shortly after I arrived at my hotel south of downtown, I took a mile or so walk. I saw only two other pedestrians on my constitutional—both, apparently, homeless."

    To my point, I'm confused at the contradictory nature of the article. Further supporting my confusion, why is the article stating that the city is "implementing policies that will make it more like Portland, Oregon," when (I thought) Portland was notoriously liberal? I think this city is cool in structure, but I am questioning the validity of how traditionally conservative Mesa is. Perhaps this is the future of a more trendy conservative city.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Reading about Mesa, it seems like more of a 50s-70s style conservatism than the newer libertarian conservatism. The notion of organic community is important to that kind of religious and cultural ideology, even if they reject heavy state involvement in welfare and planning as too radical. I think that conservative approach to community is why they accept limited approaches to infrastructure and environmentalism in a limited manner. I thought this paragraph was revealing,

    "It also helps that bond issues go to specific projects, and cover only a specific amount of money. That’s different from funding a social program, or simply forking over higher taxes and hoping that the extra funds go where the government says they’re going. “People are OK with investing in their communities,” says Smith. “People don’t trust programs. They trust … tangible results.” And because the bonds are earmarked to specific projects, even skinflint Mesa residents feel OK about voting yes. Glover also thinks the referendum process itself leads to more support for infrastructure projects. “We look to the voters to say what [they would] like to see done in the city. We try to have them be more engaged,” he says."

    ReplyDelete
  3. Self Storage– Best Storage Solutions providers you with the best facility and service you are looking for and deserve for all of your storage needs in Dubai. Here’s how our Storage in Dubai solution works as – our experienced professional movers Dubai will come to your door step, pack and pick up the items that you want to put in storage space and take them to our warehouse facility.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Avail of reliable storage facilities in Dubai to securely store your belongings. Be it
    furniture storageor office equipment storage, we cover a wide range. Storage Space and Warehouse Facility Dubai. In search of the right managed storage space in Dubai to store and manage your goods and products? Looking for warehouse storage Dubai? MH Technical Services movers have separate warehouses designed for commercial and personal uses, Contact Us today. Get a Free Quote. We offer warehouse facility and cargo services in Dubai & UAE.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Storage in Dubai is now easy with Home Storage Dubai. Affordable & Premium storage facility with exceptional customer services. Self-Storage Dubai, Best storage UAE, Affordable moving company in Dubai, Self-Storage units, Storage space, Storage services, Storage service in Abu Dhabi. Modern Storage Solutions For All Your Personal Needs – Free Up Your Home Space Today. Moving Home? Renovating? Or Just Need More Space? Get A Free Quote from Us Today.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Apartment Painting Dubai is the best painting company in Dubai. We offer you flawless wall painting services in Dubai. We give a perfect finish to the interior and exterior. Our PROFESSIONAL Painters in Dubai offers home and villa painting services for 10+ years. Affordable Wall Painting Services by Expert Painters in Dubai for house painting solution in Dubai, villa painting Dubai,
    apartment painting Dubai.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Looking to hire a Sober driver in Dubai? Sober Driver Dubai Most Trusted Driver In Dubai UAE. Sober Driver app is designed to provide you with comforting and fast experience of booking a driver in Dubai and UAE. Professional safe driver Dubai drives you home safely, book reliable & designated safer driver. Get driver in 20 minutes starting from 80 AED only. Sober Driver Dubai offers world-class chauffeur services in Dubai at cheapest prices.

    ReplyDelete
  8. We are the professional furniture packers furniture packers and movers in Dubai. Providing Cheapest Movers Service, Reliable and Hassle-free Service. We are expert and professional in packing and moving your office furniture in Dubai. Our office move action plans are carefully drawn up to minimize the loss or damages of your office furniture.

    ReplyDelete